A street vendor smartly selling umbrellas as heavy rain starts to fall, perfectly illustrating brilliant marketing relevance.
Marketing Fundamentals

Why Does Marketing Relevance Depend on More Than Personalisation?

Rajnish Kumar · · 3 min read

Are your personalized ads failing? Discover how building brilliant marketing relevance drives explosive brand growth.

Looking for a Shorter Overview?

Key Moments

Relevance is Contextual

True marketing relevance means addressing the buyer's current situation rather than using outdated personal information.

Pharmacy Seasonal Offer

A pharmacy sends a relevant winter cough‑medicine ad, matching present health needs and driving immediate sales.

Street Vendor Umbrella

A street vendor instantly sells umbrellas when rain starts, illustrating marketing relevance through immediate need fulfillment.

Airline Ban Mistake

An airline promotes flights during a travel ban, causing frustration and app uninstalls due to tone‑deaf messaging.

When a buyer purchases a washing machine online on Tuesday, the shopping app shows them ten ads for more washing machines on Wednesday. But the person has just bought one and will not buy another today. This failure shows exactly why marketing relevance requires far more than simple data collection. 

A brand may know a buyer’s exact age and past shopping habits, but if it offers the wrong item at the wrong time, the message fails entirely. According to Gartner consumer research, brands that focus only on current customer needs perform much better than those relying on old personal data. 

True marketing relevance means understanding the exact situation a buyer faces right now.

True marketing relevance means understanding the exact situation a buyer faces right now. Knowing his name means nothing if he does not need the item today.

Mechanics of Marketing Relevance

Many companies believe personalisation is the only strategy that matters. They buy expensive software to track user data. They send messages claiming they chose a special item just for one person. But a buyer may have recently lost his job and wants to save money. 

The company then offers him an expensive holiday package because he bought one last year. Since the offer ignores his current situation, it lacks marketing relevance. The personalisation actually makes the company look careless.

Marketing experts at Forrester Research report a clear finding about this behaviour. Consumers feel deeply annoyed when brands use their personal details without offering any real help. 

As we discussed in our recent article about product language, choosing the right descriptive words matters greatly. But even the best words fail without strong marketing relevance. A company must solve a problem the buyer is actually facing today. Just printing his name on a discount coupon does not persuade him to pay cash.

Most advertising software only tracks past actions. A person books a hotel room in Delhi for a weekend trip. The next week, the travel company keeps sending him daily offers for more Delhi hotels. 

The brand thinks it is doing a great job because the data matches his past trip. This mistake completely ignores marketing relevance. The person has already finished his trip. He returned home to Patna and will not book another hotel in Delhi immediately. The brand spends advertising money on a useless offer. 

A highly successful business focuses on the present instead. A pharmacy sends a basic cough medicine offer during the first week of winter. The message does not use anyone’s first name. It simply addresses a current seasonal problem. 

This broad message has perfect marketing relevance. The sick buyer sees the offer, feels understood, and pays his money immediately. Correct timing always brings in more money than outdated personal data files.

A seller must consider the outside world before asking for money. An airline company tries to sell international flight tickets during a major national travel ban. It uses highly personalised emails that show the customer’s favourite holiday spots. 

The customer reads the email and feels deeply frustrated. The company completely ignored the national situation. The customer uninstalls the application because the brand does not know what is happening outside.

A wise business owner adjusts his offers based on ground reality to maintain marketing relevance. If heavy rain starts falling, a street vendor begins selling umbrellas. He does not ask buyers for any information before selling. He simply provides the exact item needed at that moment. That direct action is the best example of marketing relevance.

To make a brand profitable, it must stop relying on old data and customers’ purchase histories. The company should focus on what buyers actually need right now. True marketing relevance requires the seller to pay attention to the present moment.

Loved this article? Read more insightful articles on Brand Custodian.

–Written by Rajnish Kumar, a copywriter and strategist with a background in fast-paced journalism, who explores the gap between what brands promise and how consumers actually behave.

Questions Answered

Why do personalized ads often fail to engage customers?

Because they ignore the buyer’s current needs and context entirely.

How can marketers achieve true relevance in their messaging?

By focusing on real‑time situations rather than historical data alone.

What real‑world examples show the power of present‑moment marketing?

Seasonal medicine offers and on‑the‑spot umbrella sales illustrate immediate relevance.

What are the consequences of ignoring current events in marketing?

Customer frustration, lost trust, and wasted advertising spend for the brand.

Recommended for you

View section